By a mere coincidence, I recently had the chance to watch two
movies by acclaimed producer and director Stanley Kramer. This independent film
maker struggled to stay away from the shackles of studios in America ,
producing and directing some of the finest films in Hollywood .
Kramer’s films had simple yet powerful themes that find resonance even today. I
watched two of his famous courtroom dramas, Inherit the Wind and Judgement at Nuremberg
which released only a year apart and were critically and commercially
acclaimed.
Apart from the fact that they were both directed by Kramer,
these movies have another factor in common, veteran actor Spencer Tracy.
Playing a prosecution lawyer in Inherit the wind and a judge in Judgement at Nuremberg ,
Tracy essays both these roles with
the same restraint and dignity.
Kramer’s legal dramas share several central themes. Foremost
amongst these is the emphasis on the individual as an agent of change. In a
world where hatred, bigotry and intolerance lie in wait of their next prey, men
and women have to exercise their better judgement and think independently of
what the mass opinion is. Kramer places a tremendous responsibility on us as
human beings to pause and think for ourselves.
Inherit the Wind, based on the famous Monkey Trials of 1925, tells the story of a teacher who was arrested for teachingDarwin ’s theory of
evolution. The local authorities imprison him for teaching that man evolved
from micro organisms. As per the laws of ‘Holy’ Hillsborough teaching anything
that went against the Bible was a punishable offence. When school teacher
Bertram Cates introduces Darwin ’s
theory of evolution and questions how the world around us was created he becomes
a religious traitor.
The trial that follows sees Spencer Tracy defend Cates, and more importantly, defend the right to think. A seemingly innocuous exchange in the beginning of the film is in fact a brilliant summary of what Kramer is trying to say. At a council meeting, the religious head of the community stands up and says that the herd will return to their shepherd. Another member of the council feels offended and says, “but we aren't sheep”. This statement is the crux of 'Inherit the wind'. We are thinking creatures. That’s what separates us from animals, and punishing a man for exercising his right to think is a dangerous precedent.
Inherit the Wind, based on the famous Monkey Trials of 1925, tells the story of a teacher who was arrested for teaching
The trial that follows sees Spencer Tracy defend Cates, and more importantly, defend the right to think. A seemingly innocuous exchange in the beginning of the film is in fact a brilliant summary of what Kramer is trying to say. At a council meeting, the religious head of the community stands up and says that the herd will return to their shepherd. Another member of the council feels offended and says, “but we aren't sheep”. This statement is the crux of 'Inherit the wind'. We are thinking creatures. That’s what separates us from animals, and punishing a man for exercising his right to think is a dangerous precedent.
Judgement at Nuremberg
is based on an issue of far more global significance. Post the Second World
War, German officials who were part of Hitler’s government and those who
carried out gruesome crimes against the Jews were tried by American courts of
justice. The film dramatizes one such
trial which is representative of the proceedings conducted in post war Germany .
On trial are three prominent judges who violated and misused laws sending
thousands of innocent people to their death, compulsory sterilization or imprisonment. While the setting of the film is much larger, it addresses issues
reflected in Inherit the Wind. As Spencer Tracy, playing a judge at the trial
says, it comes down to each and every individual. He states that injustice to
even one man is as heinous as injustice to an entire community. Kramer
emphasizes the importance of taking a stand, especially when it is most
difficult to take a stand. Burt
Lancaster very effectively underplays the role of former German hero, Ernst
Janning who confesses that the claims of the average German that they didn’t
know the enormity of the crimes is false. They never tried to know, they never
tried to stop it. If every judge in the Ministry of Justice set up by Hitler
had refused to follow the cruel autocratic laws of the land, perhaps the
history of the world would not reek with blood of six million Jews.
Both these courtroom dramas also raise another recurrent dilemma-
which duty is more important, loyalty to one self or loyalty to one’s
occupation and the rules that restrict as professionally and socially? Should
Bertram Cates plead guilty so that he is no longer an outcast within his
community, or should he stand by what he really believes in? Ernst Janning could
have objected to the laws he abhorred, resigned but refused to comply, but he
chose public fame over private shame.
Janning abhors what he has done, but the confession of sins is
too little too late. As Tracy tells
him in the final scene of the film, that when the first innocent man was
sentenced to death, Janning and his fellow judges knew the dangers of the path
they were headed down. Kramer highlights how we willingly suspend disbelief, or even suspend our entire belief
system in our uncontrollable urge to be acceptable. Our
mind is so powerful that we can virtually convince ourselves of anything. Worse
still we can be convinced by the agents of intolerance and evil. The men who
caused the deaths of millions in Germany
believed that they were doing something to support their country, while the
residents of Hillsborough donned blindfolds of religion to avoid seeing the
truth.
Kramer takes care to paint the several shades of grey
ambiguities, between right and wrong, good and evil. While Judgement at Nuremberg
is critical of German indifference and tolerance of the unspeakable evil that
was in their neighbourhood, the director takes care to never mount the moral
high horse. He takes care to show how nations around the world have an equal hand in what
happened by their complicit silence. In fact the Americans operating the courts
of justice in Germany
have themselves committed horrific crimes in Hiroshima
and Nagasaki by dropping nuclear
bombs that killed millions of innocent people.
It is interesting to see the impact of Charles Darwin and
his research findings on cinema and literature of from the Victorian and Modern
period. Inherit the Wind is set in the 1920’s, and the turmoil created by
scientific research is felt more deeply. Having been told for years that, the world was created in seven days by
God, the citizens of Hillsborough find Darwin
discomforting. However what is even more uncomfortable is being forced to
unlearn what they have considered the truth of their existence. They aren't as
offended as they are scared of the new and the unknown.
Kramer makes clever use of some ofDarwin ’s other theories
such as survival of the fittest. This is done by taking some seemingly innocent
shots of the meals eaten by the two lawyers. While Drummond chooses a simple
sandwich and looks after his health, Brady overeats and indulges in fried
chicken on an everyday basis. So while he dies at the end of the film with a
ruptured stomach, Drummond makes it out of the heated courtroom battle with his
physical and mental faculties intact. Hitler took over the order of natural selection
himself by choosing to kill and sterilize those men and women he believed were in
the way of Germany ’s
progress. Ironically, German laws left thousands of ordinary Germans maimed or
mentally unstable. Like the citizens of Hillsborough, who are bound by unfair
and archaic laws, the citizens of Germany
too suffered ironically at the hands of their own ruler.The precarious position of science in our lives is a theme reflected in both these films. While on the one hand it is knowledge, advancement, when misused, like it was by the Nazis, it can have catastrophic consequences.
Kramer makes clever use of some of
These films don’t have great technical finesse, production
values or any special emphasis on making each frame a portrait. However they
have copious amounts of good intention and genuine concern at the diminishing
strength of character and growing intolerance. Though made over 50 years ago
and based on events that happened even earlier, Inherit the Wind and Judgement
at Nuremberg and movies whose
emphasis of strength of character, and humanity find resonance even today. Or
as Stanley Kramer put it in his own words “ I tried to make movies that lasted, about
issues that would not go away”.