personagraphs js sdk

Tuesday, October 29, 2013

KRAMER VS KRAMER


By a mere coincidence, I recently had the chance to watch two movies by acclaimed producer and director Stanley Kramer. This independent film maker struggled to stay away from the shackles of studios in America, producing and directing some of the finest films in Hollywood. Kramer’s films had simple yet powerful themes that find resonance even today. I watched two of his famous courtroom dramas, Inherit the Wind and Judgement at Nuremberg which released only a year apart and were critically and commercially acclaimed.
Apart from the fact that they were both directed by Kramer, these movies have another factor in common, veteran actor Spencer Tracy. Playing a prosecution lawyer in Inherit the wind and a judge in Judgement at Nuremberg, Tracy essays both these roles with the same restraint and dignity.

Kramer’s legal dramas share several central themes. Foremost amongst these is the emphasis on the individual as an agent of change. In a world where hatred, bigotry and intolerance lie in wait of their next prey, men and women have to exercise their better judgement and think independently of what the mass opinion is. Kramer places a tremendous responsibility on us as human beings to pause and think for ourselves.
 Inherit the Wind, based on the famous Monkey Trials of 1925, tells the story of a teacher who was arrested for teaching Darwin’s theory of evolution. The local authorities imprison him for teaching that man evolved from micro organisms. As per the laws of ‘Holy’ Hillsborough teaching anything that went against the Bible was a punishable offence. When school teacher Bertram Cates introduces Darwin’s theory of evolution and questions how the world around us was created he becomes a religious traitor.
The trial that follows sees Spencer Tracy defend Cates, and more importantly, defend the right to think. A seemingly innocuous exchange in the beginning of the film is in fact a brilliant summary of what Kramer is trying to say. At a council meeting, the religious head of the community stands up and says that the herd will return to their shepherd. Another member of the council feels offended and says, “but we aren't sheep”.  This statement is the crux of 'Inherit the wind'. We are thinking creatures. That’s what separates us from animals, and punishing a man for exercising his right to think is a dangerous precedent.

Judgement at Nuremberg is based on an issue of far more global significance. Post the Second World War, German officials who were part of Hitler’s government and those who carried out gruesome crimes against the Jews were tried by American courts of justice.  The film dramatizes one such trial which is representative of the proceedings conducted in post war Germany. On trial are three prominent judges who violated and misused laws sending thousands of innocent people to their death, compulsory sterilization or imprisonment. While the setting of the film is much larger, it addresses issues reflected in Inherit the Wind. As Spencer Tracy, playing a judge at the trial says, it comes down to each and every individual. He states that injustice to even one man is as heinous as injustice to an entire community. Kramer emphasizes the importance of taking a stand, especially when it is most difficult to take a stand. Burt Lancaster very effectively underplays the role of former German hero, Ernst Janning who confesses that the claims of the average German that they didn’t know the enormity of the crimes is false. They never tried to know, they never tried to stop it. If every judge in the Ministry of Justice set up by Hitler had refused to follow the cruel autocratic laws of the land, perhaps the history of the world would not reek with blood of six million Jews.

Both these courtroom dramas also raise another recurrent dilemma- which duty is more important, loyalty to one self or loyalty to one’s occupation and the rules that restrict as professionally and socially? Should Bertram Cates plead guilty so that he is no longer an outcast within his community, or should he stand by what he really believes in? Ernst Janning could have objected to the laws he abhorred, resigned but refused to comply, but he chose public fame over private shame.
Janning abhors what he has done, but the confession of sins is too little too late. As Tracy tells him in the final scene of the film, that when the first innocent man was sentenced to death, Janning and his fellow judges knew the dangers of the path they were headed down. Kramer highlights how we willingly suspend disbelief, or even suspend our entire belief system in our uncontrollable urge to be acceptable. Our mind is so powerful that we can virtually convince ourselves of anything. Worse still we can be convinced by the agents of intolerance and evil. The men who caused the deaths of millions in Germany believed that they were doing something to support their country, while the residents of Hillsborough donned blindfolds of religion to avoid seeing the truth.

Kramer takes care to paint the several shades of grey ambiguities, between right and wrong, good and evil. While Judgement at Nuremberg is critical of German indifference and tolerance of the unspeakable evil that was in their neighbourhood, the director takes care to never mount the moral high horse.  He takes care to show how nations around the world have an equal hand in what happened by their complicit silence. In fact the Americans operating the courts of justice in Germany have themselves committed horrific crimes in Hiroshima and Nagasaki by dropping nuclear bombs that killed millions of innocent people.

It is interesting to see the impact of Charles Darwin and his research findings on cinema and literature of from the Victorian and Modern period. Inherit the Wind is set in the 1920’s, and the turmoil created by scientific research is felt more deeply. Having been told for years that, the world was created in seven days by God, the citizens of Hillsborough find Darwin discomforting. However what is even more uncomfortable is being forced to unlearn what they have considered the truth of their existence. They aren't as offended as they are scared of the new and the unknown.
Kramer makes clever use of some of Darwin’s other theories such as survival of the fittest. This is done by taking some seemingly innocent shots of the meals eaten by the two lawyers. While Drummond chooses a simple sandwich and looks after his health, Brady overeats and indulges in fried chicken on an everyday basis. So while he dies at the end of the film with a ruptured stomach, Drummond makes it out of the heated courtroom battle with his physical and mental faculties intact. Hitler took over the order of natural selection himself by choosing to kill and sterilize those men and women he believed were in the way of Germany’s progress. Ironically, German laws left thousands of ordinary Germans maimed or mentally unstable. Like the citizens of Hillsborough, who are bound by unfair and archaic laws, the citizens of Germany too suffered ironically at the hands of their own ruler.The precarious position of science in our lives is a theme reflected in both these films. While on the one hand it is knowledge, advancement, when misused, like it was by the Nazis, it can have catastrophic consequences. 

These films don’t have great technical finesse, production values or any special emphasis on making each frame a portrait. However they have copious amounts of good intention and genuine concern at the diminishing strength of character and growing intolerance. Though made over 50 years ago and based on events that happened even earlier, Inherit the Wind and Judgement at Nuremberg and movies whose emphasis of strength of character, and humanity find resonance even today. Or as Stanley Kramer put it in his own words “ I tried to make movies that lasted, about issues that would not go away”.


Monday, October 21, 2013

Rope and the crisis of masculinity


I ended up seeing Rope after many years the other day. Thanks to my unusual grandfather who spent all his life on ships and at sea but at heart is a film studies student who knowledge of American and British films is quite encyclopedic. Then I decided to write about it, for my other grandfather whom I lost recently. Brilliant and multifaceted, he was also my biggest fan and I think had much more faith in me then I ever will. I am saddened when I realise that he will never read anything I write again. Thanks to both these wise old gentlemen I proceeded to watch Alfred Hitchcock’s Rope with the husband.

The plot of the film is fairly simple. Brandon and Philip strangle their old friend David and then hide his body in a large chest in their apartment. In a macabre turn of events they then host a dinner party in their house, serving food off the same chest that they have put David in. Unfortunately for the murderous twosome, their ex school master Rupert who is one of the guests that evening, smells a rat. He begins his own investigations which prove to be Brandon and Philip’s undoing.  While on the surface, Rope is a murder mystery, the film has far from subliminal hints at the homosexual undertones to Brandon and Philip’s relationship. They share an apartment, take frequent trips together and in the course of the film organise a dinner party together, playing the perfect hosts who like any married couple who try to conceal any personal problems in front of guests.

For long being a man has had certain pre conceived notions, heterosexuality, and virility being two primary ones. A man has consistently been projected in cinema and popular culture as being physically strong, ambitious, professionally successful, the provider of financial security and in search for a fairly stereotypical female companion.  Rope taps into a constant sense of insecurity that most men seem to carry around of just how masculine they actually are. While a lot has been said over the years about how a woman must behave and present herself, men are always grappling with ways to be appreciated amongst others in their own gender. What is the norm for a man? Is he supposed to be a feminist and risk being called henpecked? Or is he supposed retain a moderately patriarchal personality? Is he supposed to share equal responsibilities at home and work, or encourage a clear demarcation of roles between him and his spouse? As many rules as there are on what makes a woman ideal, there seem to be much performance anxiety for a man-to play the part of a MAN, in the house and outside.
David, the victim is the textbook heterosexual man. White, male, wealthy parents, successful career, and now engaged to a beautiful woman, he is the pin up boy for what is conventionally acceptable and applauded. The entire film has numerous dialogues where the characters compare lifestyle choices. Brandon vociferously argues that a certain group of people are intellectually superior and not inclined to live by the moral codes and norms of society. Others who are ‘weak’ and inclined to conform are inferior and do not deserve to live. As the film progresses one sees clear groups forming amongst the guests at the party. David’s father, his aunt and fiance seem to share a different opinion to that of Brandon, Rupert and Philip.
 Brandon’s cocky demeanor and constant projection of confidence and superiority conceal a deep seated insecurity about his identity and the way he is perceived by society. On the face of it he is a wealthy, single white male, good looking and well connected. However beneath the veneer of a rehearsed poise and sophistication lies a man deeply confused and unable to come to terms with himself. This anxiety becomes most evident in the last couple of scenes in the film where is desperately seeks Rupert’s approval. He expects Rupert to understand what drove him to commit this crime, perhaps because it was Rupert who first made him realise, or confront his sexual orientation.
The narrative very clearly reveals that Rupert has spent vacations in Brandon’s farmhouse when he and Philip were young. His proximity with the two, both emotional and physical indicates that either Brandon or Philip, or both were his partners when they were teenagers. Brandon inviting his former headmaster seems to indicate that perhaps subconsciously, he wanted to be caught. The moment Rupert opens the chest in Brandon’s presence his body becomes Brandon’s sacrificial offering to the man whose affections and admiration he desires.
One is forced to consider if the murder is Brandon’s way of asserting the superiority of his sexual choice over the more conventionally accepted choice of heterosexuality. When he says that David is inferior and ordinary, is he referring to David’s intelligence or his sexual orientation? In an age when homosexuality was literally in the closet, Brandon shuts his dead friend into a chest, freeing himself from a self imposed closet. His reaction to David’s strangling and the dialogue at this juncture are particularly interesting. As the life leaves David’s body, Brandon almost seems to climax sexually, then mentioning that the body has gone limp. It is also interesting to note that he is standing behind David, a position almost indicative of anal intercourse amongst homosexual men.

When looked at from the point of view of sexual orientation, Brandon and Philip almost seem pitiful. Unable to be vocal about their sexual choice, almost made impotent by social norms, they seem to find release, both sexual and emotional by subverting heterosexuality, though in a definitely drastic and unacceptable manner. However Rupert opens the chest, returning the universe to its conventional balance, firing a shot that will alert cops, and put David’s killers behind bars. By setting David’s body free, he returns Brandon and Philip into the closet, separating them from society again, this time through imprisonment. 

Wednesday, September 25, 2013

Unheard Rebecca



The first time I read Rebecca I fell in love with the book. The haunting, sometimes thrilling often heart wrenching novel by Daphne du maurier made me an instant fan of the author and I have ever since recommended the book to many people wanting a good book to read. However the other day I saw a cinematic adaptation of the movie and for the first time I saw the story in a completely different light. While the novel is an extremely well written and intelligent spin on traditional ghost stories and blue beard room tales of dead ex wives, the film in its effort to stay true to the book drags endlessly. Perhaps we have grown up on a diet of high adrenaline thrillers where the camera twitches endlessly or horror films where dead people actually reappear to haunt the living. But there in lies the brilliance of Rebecca. She speaks no lines, she never makes any ghoulish appearances and yet in her absence she is omniscient, ever present and omni potent. Du Maurier through some very clever prose depicts how often the absence of a person occupies greater space than a living being. I have never been a great Lawrence Olivier fan and while he does seem quite convincing as the attractive but gloomy Maxin de Winter, he seems too self absorbed as a character (which is perhaps a good thing) and as an actor to really do anything much for the film.
However what really struck me about the film that I had never noticed before was the subliminal or not so subliminal subtext on women and their nature and the qualities that a wife must have. I have no clear knowledge about Daphne Du Maurier’s stand on feminism or the position of women in society but it is interesting how she puts the shy, gauche, inexperienced protagonist in the spotlight of our sympathy and builds up the novel to a point where it is revealed that the seemingly dazzling, talented and beautiful Rebecca was actually unfaithful and deceitful. I had never looked at Rebecca as a text which felt that being an anonymous but utterly domesticated Mrs. De Winter, was better than being Rebecca who life was more than the traditional life cut out for the female gender .Was Rebecca punished for being so beautiful that every man desired her? Did the author perceive an independent, almost alpha female personality a threat to the social and moral fabric of society? As the novel describes her Rebecca is a beautiful and accomplished woman who charms anyone and everyone who meets her. She is the “perfect hostess”, a socialite if one might call her of that age and a woman whose personality cannot be suppressed within the walls of Manderlay. The other characters in the novel and in the film seem to idolise her and are also ‘haunted’ by her memories. From the way the fire is made in a room to the writing papers, napkins, and linen in drawers, everything has her mark on it. Not a family seal, not the crest of the De winter family but her name, the almost ominous R, sewn, stamped and printed onto everything that once belonged to her.  She has beauty, breeding and brains as Maxim says, everything that a man can want in a wife and yet he is unable to pin her down, control her, something perhaps a man wants more in his wife. Perhaps her only fault was her refusal to be loyal to her husband. A woman who looked at sex as something that could be merely an indulgence of the wealthy and more radically the fairer sex, and not something that was a by product of a marriage. While men for centuries have been unfaithful in marriages, had mistresses, visited courtesans and financed beer bars and brothels, women have always been expected to stay faithful and more importantly silent.  I wonder if that explains Maxim’s hatred for her. The fact that she was so much more than just Mrs. De winter… Unlike his second wife whose first name is never revealed through the book, his first wife had an irrepressible quality about her. She was more popular than him, perhaps even more intelligent than him and most importantly she had a mind of her own. She would take her own decisions. The protagonist of the book; the second wife, does very little but sketch occasionally and run around like the pet dog of the house Jasper, observing everything but too scared to speak or take control of any situation. In fact she seems to be more in awe of her husband than in love with him which is why she tolerates his patronising attitude and his irritating habit of calling her ‘child’ and then treating her like one. She is so grateful or honoured to be married to such a rich man, almost rescued by a prince charming that she seemingly has no aspirations or expectations from a husband. So awfully lacking is she in self esteem that she declares herself “ I am not the sort of person that men marry”. Rebecca on the other hand makes such a splendid success of even her part as the ideal wife that Maxim has no choice but to ignore her follies. She is almost the ‘man’ in the relationship, making her own decisions, and expecting Maxim to turn a blind eye like many a wife would to her spouse’s roving eye.
One can argue that the author was probably making the average girl reading her novel feel good about not being “the most beautiful creature” anyone has ever set their eyes or perhaps just writing a very clever ghost story, but I cant shake off the feeling that she was trying to say something more. Declare that the ‘real virtues’ a man looks for in his wife are sincerity, kindliness and decency and not beauty, wit and intelligence as the conversation between Frank and the second wife very cleverly mentions. The lady who was quite content with basking in Maxim’s reflected glory and being an anonymous entity whose name was secondary to her being Mrs. DeWinter, survives and gets the hero while the woman whose popularity spilt over the four walls of her home had to die a painful death. The story also chooses an interesting end to the character of Mrs. Danvers. While the book perhaps limited her obsession to looking after Rebecca’s dressing table, writing paper and fur coats, the film is very suggestive of a more homo erotic attraction towards her mistress. The manner in which she preserves and specially mentions where she keeps Rebecca’s underwear or caresses her see-through night gown indicates more than just the ardent loyalty of a housekeeper. Interestingly, Mrs. Danvers too suffers a painful death, committing suicide of a different kind when she burns herself to death by setting the house on fire and stays in Recca’s room till the house burns down. A woman who feels that Rebecca’s way of life was right and admirable, has to suffer a painful death like her while also perhaps commenting on the fact that such intimacy whether mental or physical with another woman, or a possibly an alternative sexuality, or bisexuality is something that cannot and should not be allowed to survive. Such is Rebecca’s aura that even death cannot extinguish her presence and charisma. Even the absence of her makes her present, overcoming even death when her body is found at the bottom of the ocean. A woman who can manipulate men and make them weak in her presence is made very clearly immoral and undesirable. Rebecca dies while her philandering ‘cousin’ Mr. Flavel, escapes scot free with no blackmail gains and just mild embarrassment. Most importantly we never hear her side of the story. We will never really know what made her the way she was and if she chose to be unfaithful then what was the reason.  It is interesting how spaces are segregated for the renegade women in literature. While much earlier Charlotte Bronte put the mad woman in the attic, Rebecca is allotted a west wing and a cottage by the sea where she conducts her clandestine affairs. Both women are described as having dark hair and a certain initial exotic appeal. In fact, both the heros say that they fell for the women in their youth but then realised that their marriages were a mistake. Unlike the mad woman in the attic who had her say thanks to psychologists, feminists and writers, Rebecca will always remain the most subjective character-seen from everybody’s eyes except her own and spoken for and about by numerous people, but never given a chance to speak for herself. 

Thursday, January 17, 2013

Na Matru ka, na Bijli ka yeh Mandola





Vishal Bharadwaj is the bard’s most loyal fan. Virtually every film of his has been inspired either in style or content by Shakespeare and his work.The only difference here is that Bharadwaj seems to have revised his Samuel Beckett as well. Like Vladimir and Estragon in Waiting for Godot, the citizens of this village are waiting for Mao to show them the way. Communism meets existentialism in this absurd satire where God is ridiculed and the heavens open up only to bring misery and destruction to the villagers of Mandola.

So quite evidently, there is something rotten in the state of Mandola. MKBKM establishes very early that this film is about disease and the absurdity and emptiness of life. The disease is of mind, of body and a society tottering drunkenly on the brink of mindless industrialisation.
For Mandola and his subjects, to be or not be, that is the question. To be a ruthless capitalist or a soft hearted socialist, to use your daughter or not, to accept defeat and surrender to the rich or to fight, the characters face many questions of morality and are unable to make a decision either way. Perhaps this incomplete existence is characterised by the Eunuch in the movie. Thankfully unlike most Hindi films, this one is never ridiculed and is treated with dignity. But then again, Vishal Bharadwaj isn’t just another director. Perhaps amongst the few good men of Bollywood, Vishal Bharadwaj is the foremost amongst a dying specie- a good director.

The movie gets off to quite a crackling start, complete with a stretch limo in a field to
a brand of country liquor called gulabbo, who thankfully is not another item girl.
‘By night one way, by day another’. Harry the drunken commie villager transforms into quite a sober ogre by day. While at night he leads the villagers to revolt against himself, by day he is quite willing to dispose off his darling daughter Bijlee as collateral to seal a deal with Chaudhary devi. Joining the club is a pink buffalo who appears as a withdrawal symptom, and African dancers who are perhaps as out of place in Haryana, as the factories and malls will be in their fields. Like the Africans were enslaved and displaced in the past, the villagers of Mandola too face a similar future. Alienated from their lands, and sold off by their master, the enslaved villagers have no where to go. As Arya Babbar quips, “ unhe pata bhi nahin chala ki voh bik gaye”

MKBKM is also perhaps the most unusual take on Macbeth, and the director declares as much. A loyal servant goes against his master but only this time Lady Macbeth will be Duncan’s undoing thanks to his almost incestuous proximity to her. Quite like the incestuous relationship between the corporate world and politicians in our economy. Shabana Azmi and Pankaj Kapur play footsie under the table at meetings, and get their children married in a strictly professional way.

Pankaj Kapur’s dual character is perhaps a reflection of the duplicity in the development of our country. The struggle between the Mandola vasis and Harry is actually a struggle within Harry himself. The only person he needs to overcome is himself. The actor shines in a role that is layered and complex. Whether its his drunk buffoonery or his sober sadism, Kapur has never been in better form. Inspite of age and looks not being on his side, the man is so good that Imran Khan and Anushka Sharma become virtually non existent. She shines in a scene towards the end and for a brief moment Kapoor is no longer the centre of attention. Maybe the woman should focus on showing less skin and displaying more histrionics. God knows she is perhaps one of the few new actresses who looks good and can emote.

The unfortunate tragic flaw of MKBKM is it tries to say too much and keeps saying it for too long. There are completely unnecessary sequences with Imran Khan and Kapur, and with every scene the thespian only makes it more obvious that Khan has some serious acting skills to pick up. Vishal Bharadwaj could transform Saif Ali Khan from uber cool NRI boy to pure rustic evil, but unfortunately, Imran Khan grows a beard and there ends his effort. Shabana Azmi is scrumptious as the manipulative and corrupt Chaudhary Devi. With all the sati savitri’s populating television, its refreshing to see a woman be so unabashedly evil. She gets the best monologue of the film where she explains with utmost conviction, the necessity of corruption. Arya Babbar is also surprisingly good, and one cant help but feel allusions to certain other mother-son jodis who are leading this nation to nowhere particular.

What is really gratifying though is that Vishal Bharadwaj has the courage to make films that break the clutter every single time. One can see that as he starts working with A list actors, his films are acquiring a more commercial feel, complete with skimpily clad women emerging from lakes. However as a director and story teller, he makes profanity sounds stylish, and cuss words comic. He is not afraid to be an intellectual who makes references to Shakespeare that most people won’t get, but thankfully he never stoops to the level of saans kahan se le aur pade kahan se. Bravo Mr. Bharadwaj! While your counterparts are going south, or just round and round, you continue to forge your own path…This movie is neither Matru ka na Bijlee ka… I’d watch it again, just for Mandola.